Template talk:KnownRatingList

Some quick notes:

• Great job on finding a quote for Golem! I have been looking for one, and can't believe I missed it.
• I placed the trump types back in, but with a smaller font and with the words Trump type in front of it.
• Tecton is indeed a Tinker with Shaker capabilities, but might not be a Tinker (Shaker). He could be a Tinker/Shaker instead, in the same vein that Chariot is a Tinker/Mover. We don't know. RainDance299 (talk) 17:21, October 27, 2016 (UTC)

New edits

Hello again! Some quick notes again:

• Purity. Great job on finding the WoG in question. I did make some edits, since yours screwed with the table a bit: [1] So now also appears on the Breaker page.
• Scrub. You made some chances here, which I (somewhat) disagree with:
  • Listing Scrub simply as a Blaster/Shaker 8 to 10 looses some detail compared to Blaster 8 to 10/Shaker. If you look at the ratings for some other capes, such as Vellum and Sploosh, It's possible Scrub has rating such as Shaker 3/Blaster 8. It looses a small amount of nuance.
  • Adding (low) to Scrub's Trump classification implies his is actually listed as a low Trump on the PRT books. This might not be the case, and he might not be a Trump to the PRT at all. (In the same way Purity is not considered a Breaker by them).
    • (Having said that, I think it might a good idea to add things like (low) or (high) to some ratings, I think Flechette's are listed as low while Alexandria explicitly gets high scores?)
• Myrddin. I'm not sure about this one. Being in charge of Movers certainly implies Myrddin is a Mover himself, and I certainly think he is, but the citation provided isn't of the same standard as the rest of them. I left it up but am curious about your opinion.

Talking about standards, I'm curious about your opinions here too. Should we loosen them a bit. I a character has superspeed, is that enough to list them as Mover for example?

BTW, does anyone know how much of Weaverdice is canon? RainDance299 (talk) 14:14, March 4, 2017 (UTC)

Is there a threat rating 11?

I put down Simurgh as 'Thinker >=12' because she's greater than 10 and there aren't any 11s.  I was under the impression that anything above 10 was marked as 12 meaning 'arbitrarily high', but is that ever made clear in canon or from Wildbow comments?

It doesn't make any sense. There is ratings greater than 12, so I don't think there are reasons to doubt the existence of 11. Why will the PRT skip one number on the scale? - Linig (talk) 05:56, August 2, 2017 (UTC)

Major Malfunction members

So I noticed that while Caryatid and Fume Hood (named Fume only for some reason) were present in the rating list Withdrawl, Limerick (and the other Harbingers), and Finale were not present, I believe because we know their ratings we should enter them in after all we know they have ratings and what their powers are, so i believe it would be better than having three seperate ratings for Simurgh, Ziz, Ulama, and Israfel, after all they are litterally the same thing in different fucking names.