Template talk:KnownRatingList: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 14:14, March 4, 2017

Some quick notes:

Great job on finding a quote for Golem! I have been looking for one, and can't believe I missed it.
I placed the trump types back in, but with a smaller font and with the words Trump type in front of it.
Tecton is indeed a Tinker with Shaker capabilities, but might not be a Tinker (Shaker). He could be a Tinker/Shaker instead, in the same vein that Chariot is a Tinker/Mover. We don't know. RainDance299 (talk) 17:21, October 27, 2016 (UTC)

New edits

Hello again! Some quick notes again:

Purity. Great job on finding the WoG in question. I did make some edits, since yours screwed with the table a bit: [1]
Scrub. You made some chances here, which I disagree with.
- Listing Scrub simply as a Blaster/Shaker 8 to 10 looses some detail compared to Blaster 8 to 10/Shaker. If you look at the ratings for some other capes, such as Vellum and Sploosh, It's possible Scrub has rating such as Shaker 3/Blaster 8.
- Adding (low) to Scrub's Trump classification implies his is actually listed as a low Trump on the PRT books. This might not be the case, and he might not be a Trump to the PRT at all. (In the same way the PRT is not considered a Breaker by them).
  - (Having said that, I think it might a good idea to add things like (low) or (high) to some rating, I think Flechette's are listed as low while Alexandria explicitly gets high scores?)
Myrddin. I'm not sure about this one. Being in charge of movers certainly implies Myrddin is a mover himself, and I certainly think he is, but the citation provided isn't of the same standard as the rest of them. I left it up but am curious about your opinion.

Talking about standards, I'm curious about your opinions here too. Should we loosen them a bit. I a character has superspeed, is that enough to list them as Mover for example?

BTW, does anyone know how much of Weaverdice is canon? RainDance299 (talk) 14:14, March 4, 2017 (UTC)

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 *I placed the trump types back in, but with a smaller font and with the words Trump type in front of it.
 *Tecton is indeed a Tinker with Shaker capabilities, but might not be a Tinker (Shaker). He could be a Tinker/Shaker instead, in the same vein that Chariot is a Tinker/Mover. We don't know. [[User:RainDance299|RainDance299]] ([[User talk:RainDance299|talk]]) 17:21, October 27, 2016 (UTC)
+==New edits==
+Hello again! Some quick notes again:
+*[[Purity]]. Great job on finding the WoG in question. I did make some edits, since yours screwed with the table a bit: [http://imgur.com/a/fhpCA]
+*[[Scrub]]. You made some chances here, which I disagree with.
+**Listing Scrub simply as a Blaster/Shaker 8 to 10 looses some detail compared to Blaster 8 to 10/Shaker. If you look at the ratings for some other capes, such as [[Vellum]] and [[Sploosh]], It's possible Scrub has rating such as Shaker 3/Blaster 8.
+**Adding (low) to Scrub's Trump classification implies his is actually listed as a low Trump on the PRT books. This might not be the case, and he might not be a Trump to the PRT at all. (In the same way the PRT is not considered a Breaker by them).
+***(Having said that, I think it might a good idea to add things like (low) or (high) to some rating, I think [[Flechette]]'s are listed as low while [[Alexandria]] explicitly gets high scores?)
+*[[Myrddin]]. I'm not sure about this one. Being in charge of movers certainly implies Myrddin is a mover himself, and I certainly think he is, but the citation provided isn't of the same standard as the rest of them. I left it up but am curious about your opinion.
+Talking about standards, I'm curious about your opinions here too. Should we loosen them a bit. I a character has superspeed, is that enough to list them as [[Mover]] for example?
+BTW, does anyone know how much of [[Weaverdice]] is canon? [[User:RainDance299|RainDance299]] ([[User talk:RainDance299|talk]]) 14:14, March 4, 2017 (UTC)